SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Federal Baseball

Washington Nationals vs The NL East: Worst HR Celebration In The Division?

MIAMI, FL - DECEMBER 09:  Exterior views of the New Miami Marlins Ballpark on December 9, 2011 in Miami, Florida.  (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images)

Mike Ehrmann - Getty Images

5 months ago: MIAMI, FL - DECEMBER 09: Exterior views of the New Miami Marlins Ballpark on December 9, 2011 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images)

• WORST HR CELEBRATION BATTLE: Some might have thought it was a joke when they first saw it, like the mythical spinning baseball in the early renderings of Nationals Park. They were wrong. The artist's renderings which came out before the Miami Marlins began to build their new spaceship of a ballpark included what Miami Herald writer Lomi Kriel described at the time as a, "... psychedelic roulette wheel of jumping marlins, diving seagulls and the wild colors." SB Nation writer Grant Brisbee was quoted in that Miami Herald article as well, describing the monstrosity as, "what would happen if Vikings attacked a Gloria Estefan concert by catapulting flamingos and marlins into the pyrotechnics display." Unfortunately for us all, it's actually real and it's fantastic...

Star-divide

The Miami Marlins' HR sculpture is almost complete [there's a video simulation below]. Marlins' owner Jeff Loria's [spits!]™ Red Grooms-created assault on the eyes has been brought to life, begging the question, is it the worst HR-celebration creation amongst NL East rivals? The Nationals have their submarine horn. The "AOOOOGA!" heard each time a National goes yard. It's a nod to their location at the Navy Yard and to the nation's capital's large military population. The New York Mets have their HR apple (The Big Apple, get it! [winks]), which once rose out of what appeared to be an upturned top hat and now just rises of the batter's eye each time a Met hits one over Citi Field's outfield walls. The Philadelphia Phillies have their swinging Liberty Bell which rings for dingers and is of course a nod to the Lester and Pack-designed iconic cracked bell which resides at Independence Hall in Philadelphia. The Braves...they have that annoying-a•• HR song...

"They have that tomahawk-chopping cow, but that doesn't have anything to do with home runs," a Braves fan I know said when I brought the topic up recently. "How about you ask," he suggested, "'Which team has the least ostentatious home run celebration?' The Braves are known more for their pitching anyway rather than HR's."

"I though chicks dug the long ball?"

That ended that conversation. Yes, Atlanta would likely win the "least ostentatious" home run celebration contest, but that doesn't mean fans of other NL East teams don't dislike hearing the Braves' HR song blaring over Turner Field's speakers each time Larry "Chipper" Jones or another Brave trots around the bases after yet another Turner Field home run. Give the Braves' song a listen and remind yourself, then check out the rest of the HR-related celebrations and vote below. Which NL East team's HR celebration is the worst? Have the Marlins outdone the competition? The Miami Herald article cited above included a quote by a Miami resident who said the sculpture was enough to make Mike Stanton start bunting to avoid setting the celebration off...So who's got the Worst HR Celebration in the NL East? Don't worry, we'll be back to discussing who'll get that coveted spot on the Nats' bench if they're not comfortable with Lombardozzi tomorrow...

Atlanta Braves' HR Song:


• New York Mets' HR Apple:


Washington Nationals' Sub Horn:


• Citizens Bank Park Liberty Bell:


• Miami Marlins' "psychedelic roulette wheel of jumping marlins, diving seagulls and the wild colors" [ed. note - "I wonder which stadium they borrowed the audio of cheering fans from?"]:


• Which NL East Team's HR Celebration Is the Worst?

Poll
Which NL East Team Has The Worst HR Celebration?
Miami Marlins' Psychedelic Flying Marlins? Game OVER!
180 votes
The Washington Nationals' "AOOOOOOGA!!!" Sub Horn?
29 votes
The New York Mets' Big Apple? [Get it?] Yuck?
27 votes
The Philadelphia Phillies' Liberty Bell? [What No Cheesesteak Sculpture?]
8 votes
The Atlanta Braves' Annoying HR Song?
37 votes

281 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  36 comments

Comments

I kinda like the Marlin's "thing"

I’m happy for a team that doesn’t have to take itself so seriously. It’s campy fun. The sub horn? Just annoying.

I think you're giving them too much credit...

What’s more likely? That the Marlins’ ownership group decided to have an ironic HR celebration, even though they know a lot of people won’t “get” it, or they just chose a really stupid one.

It will upstage the uniforms and make them appear more normal to the eye...

but the distraction won’t last long….

I think the first.

They’re not that clueless.

(I understand I'm going to be in the minority on the sub horn thing)
I Love The Nats Submarine Horn.....

I like the symbolism, it is unique, and besides…..it is next door to Navy Yard! I think I heard that the Padres have a similar horn though?

I think the sub horn is great on the highlights...........

have no idea the effect live….

At first it wasn’t loud enough…..could barely hear it over the cheering crowd. It could actually be a tad bit louder still. I’m still for a giant screech coming out of a huge nest above the Red Porch! BTW….did anyone ever verify RobBob’s question that the Red Porch was changing?

a giant Screech being launched out of giant slingshot atop the Red Porch and dropping a giant baseball patterned egg?..........on a shabbily built hut in the opposing bullpen?

GENIUS!!!


lookit ’em scatter!!!

Red Grooms designed the Marlin’s HR gizmo? It’s gotta be good!

I’ve grown to like the Nats sub horn.

Anyone who could create this:


can’t be all that bad.

He has some cool stuff on permanent display at the Hirshhorn.
http://hirshhorn.si.edu/visit/collection_object.asp?key=32&subkey=7840

Long Live The King!

I’m a huge Elvis fan!

I voted for the Liberty Bell

Because it resides in Philly.

Reason enough, I'll give you that.
I voted Atlanta

The song is annoying, and even sounds like they’ve changed a note or two to avoid copyright/trademark infringement, but that’s not why I voted for it. It sounds like something Carlton Banks should be dancing to, and since ATL’s fanbase doesn’t do “The Carlton” in unison, they have the worst HR thing-a-ma-bob.

Should the ATL fans adopt doing “The Carlton”, I would reverse my vote from worst to best. Until then, thumbs down to that tune.

I voted Atlanta too, especially since I believe they stole the chop from FSU. At least all the others are original in their goofiness.
I voted Atlanta because they are Atlanta...

no other reason needed…and the chop is the worst……….I always like it getting silenced by late inning opposing team homers…

Love the horn

Reminds me of the Caps horn…gets me so pumped! Hurry up, baseball.

Brazil?

The Marlins one makes me feel like I’m watching Carnivale on acid. And not in some sort of “super-sensory cool” way, more like “my head is going to explode” kinda way.

The sub horn has grown on me

Although I do miss the fireworks.

fireworks scare dogs..........but, you want some sub horn?...

9/11/11: Ian Desmond, Rick Ankiel and Ryan Zimmerman hit back-to-back-to-back homers in the third inning vs. the Astros
http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=19116291&c_id=mlb

To me, the sub horn is tantamount to doing nothing at all.

Besides, it’s not like there’s a mess of subs running up and down the Anacostia. You want a sound that reflects DC life? Try using an automobile horn.

so you on with the Screech catapult?.....maybe a trebuchet for more velocity?
See, now THAT would be cool

It would represent not only an actual effort to produce a home run celebration, but it would also be fun to watch.

and like the old dunking machine..............

celebrity guests invited to be objets du launche could be loaded prior to the AB to encourage the hitters to go long….

I had trouble sleeping when I moved from NYC because there was no background car noise
I dislike the Braves' thing the most

It’s like they couldn’t decide on a single song, and just randomly mashed three songs and a couple of sound effects together. Yawn.

[and then the song explodes!!!]
And the Nats....

mashed one thing together?

repeated in two sets of three............there's that...
I may be in the minority,

but I really couldn’t care less it there’s a HR celebration or not.

And get off my lawn!

Yeah! And

Er ...

I meant …

Dadgummit

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Federal Baseball to post a comment.